Fire & rehire usually starts with an employer wanting to change terms and conditions of employment. For example, altering hours of work or pay in a way that will disadvantage the employee.
The first step is to check whether the contract of employment contains specific flexibility wording that allows the employer to make the change they want. If it does, it’s usually fairly straight-forward to introduce the change.
It’s rare though, that substantial negative changes will be permitted by the contract. In those cases, if the employer introduces the change without the employee agreeing, the employer will be in breach of contract.
In this type of situation, the employer has no defence to their actions and will be exposed to a claim which the employee has a high chance of being successful with. For employees with at least 2 years’ service, the employer could be facing constructive unfair dismissal as well as breach of contract claims.
To minimise these risks, employers should consult with employees about the proposed changes and seek their agreement. If, ultimately, employees fail to agree and the employer is determined to introduce the changes, one option is to dismiss those employees who don’t agree – that’s the fire bit.
Defending unfair dismissal Tribunal Claims
The potential fair reason for dismissal in these situations is usually some other substantial reason (SOSR).
If the employer followed a fair and open consultation process and was reasonable in dismissing the employee for failing to agree the change, they have the prospect of being able to defend claims of unfair dismissal.
Re-engagement of employment
The employer can go one step further, and offer the employees immediate re-engagement which will be on the new, amended terms – that’s the re-hire bit.
By doing this, the employer is providing the employee with an opportunity to mitigate their loss. In other words, an employee bringing an unfair dismissal claim is under a duty to mitigate – and the employer has offered them that opportunity, thereby reducing the risk of the employee being able to obtain substantial, or any, compensation.
When an employer knows they want to make a contractual change:
- that isn’t permitted by the contract,
- is detrimental
- and if employees don’t agree, they may decide to dismiss them, they must carefully consider how many employees it affects.
If it’s 20 or more at a single establishment then this will trigger collective consultation obligations. That means consultation for a minimum of 30 or 45 days (if 100 or more employees are affected) before any dismissals can take effect, and ensuring consultation with an appropriate representative employee body. There are other procedural requirements involved, which must be followed to minimise the risk of the employer being exposed to claims or fines.
The new statutory code
On 29 March the government announced that it will be introducing a new statutory code to crack down on fire & rehire practice, and on employers who fail to engage in meaningful consultation with employees.
The aim of this Code is to build on guidance issued by Acas in November 2021 that said employers should only consider fire and rehire as a last resort. The new Code will include the parameters for employers to operate within when seeking to change terms of employment.
An unreasonable failure to act in line with a statutory code usually increases the risk of an employer being held liable and, where an employer is, an uplift in compensation of (usually) up to 25%.
Our prices & packaging
Employment & HR
Unlimited HR & Employment law support to help manage your people
- Unlimited advice from friendly HR experts via phone and email
- Employment contract review
- Employee Handbook, Policy & Document review
- Outcome driven advice to achieve results quickly
- Tribunal Defence Support
Health & Safety
Unlimited Health & Safety advice to help manage your safety requirements
- Unlimited advice from friendly Health & Safety consultants via phone and email
- Act as your Competent Person
- Risk Assessment support
- Health & Safety Policy (review or issue one)
- Safety Management System (review or issue one)
- Support on RIDDOR Investigations
- Support with HSE or Local Authority Investigations
24/7/365 access to extensive online HR & Safety templates & resources
- 24/7/365 access to 600+ online templates
- Template contract of employment
- Template letters & documents
- Essential HR policies & procedures
- Comprehensive health & safety templates including risk assessments, policies & procedures
- Easy to understand step-by-step guidance
Employment & HR & Health & Safety
Unlimited support managing your people and health & safety requirements
- All three packages combined into one.
- Includes unlimited advice from our friendly HR and Health & Safety advisors via phone or email.